DIGACHAN
    Facebook Twitter Instagram
    Latest
    • Adverty & Apex Mobile Media Announce Partnership to Offer In-Play Gaming Inventory in Canada
    • Adverty and Yazle announce exclusive in-game ad partnership in MENA region
    • Adverty and Drive Ahead! developer Dodreams announce exclusive in-game ad partnership
    • Adverty launches industry-first streaming video technology for In-Play™ ads in partnership with SeenThis
    • Adverty’s Multi-patented and Industry-leading In-game Viewability Technology BrainImpression™ Now Available Within Oracle Moat
    • Frameplay Announces New Attention Metric in Video Game Environments, Validated in Partnership with dentsu’s Attention Economy Team by First-to-Market Studies
    • Adverty appoints Jonas Söderqvist as CEO as brands wakes up to the power of in-game advertising
    • AdInMo expands its In-Game Ops Team
    Twitter
    DIGACHAN
    • About DIGA
    • News
      1. In-Game Advertising
      2. Game News
      3. View All

      Adverty & Apex Mobile Media Announce Partnership to Offer In-Play Gaming Inventory in Canada

      27 October 2022

      Adverty and Yazle announce exclusive in-game ad partnership in MENA region

      18 August 2022

      Adverty and Drive Ahead! developer Dodreams announce exclusive in-game ad partnership

      28 July 2022

      Adverty launches industry-first streaming video technology for In-Play™ ads in partnership with SeenThis

      14 July 2022

      Big Rumble Boxing: Creed Champions to be produced by a Koch Media, Survios and MGM Partnership

      8 June 2021

      Demolition Racer “Wreckfest” Out Today

      1 June 2021

      Iconic Drivers Return to the Grid for F1 2021

      18 May 2021

      Highrise City Announced

      15 May 2021

      Adverty & Apex Mobile Media Announce Partnership to Offer In-Play Gaming Inventory in Canada

      27 October 2022

      Adverty and Yazle announce exclusive in-game ad partnership in MENA region

      18 August 2022

      Adverty and Drive Ahead! developer Dodreams announce exclusive in-game ad partnership

      28 July 2022

      Adverty launches industry-first streaming video technology for In-Play™ ads in partnership with SeenThis

      14 July 2022
    • Bad Ads

      The In-Game Advertising They Don’t Show You – Part Two

      25 February 2021

      The In-Game Advertising They Don’t Show You

      17 January 2021
    • DIGA Gallery
    • Tech Links
      • Adinmo
      • Admix
      • Adverty
      • Anzu
      • Bidstack
      • Bloxbiz
      • Gadsme
      • Frameplay
      • HotPlay
      • Rapidfire
      • Sayollo
    • Contact
    DIGACHAN
    Home » News » The In-Game Advertising They Don’t Show You
    Bad Ads

    The In-Game Advertising They Don’t Show You

    By Editorial Team17 January 2021No Comments14 Mins Read
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    Within the circles of dynamic in-game advertising, whether it’s via public relation (PR) companies, social media, or sales presentations, there is still somewhat of an echo chamber. We seem to only be shown the good and the excitement of how great in-game advertising is and can be.

    Whilst we are advocates of the new style of dynamic in-game advertising (DIGA), we also want to ensure that the gamer, developer, and advertiser are all respected and represented.

    Within this article, we take a look at examples of in-game advertising implementations, that demonstrate our opinion that this is an industry in danger if some changes aren’t made. Bad examples can paint a bad picture to the outside world and could damage this new industry before it has had a chance to fully launch.

    Before we get into some of the implementation examples that we consider to be bad, we do want to highlight that there are games that demonstrate extremely high-quality outputs as well as games that are capable of this, but improvements could be made by restricting the levels of programmatic content that raises the types of questions we are asking.

    We don’t want to tar all games or implementations with the same brush, so let’s start with…

    Examples of In-Game Advertising Done Well.

    There are some great examples out there that show just how effective dynamic in-game advertising can be.

    We ultimately look for positive qualities such as:

    1. Creatives that fit the designed space
    2. Creatives that don’t distract or disrupt the gamer and gameplay
    3. Creatives that are contextually relevant to the game and the target gamer
    4. Creatives that add something to the game rather than take it away

    Here are a bunch of creatives, that really stand out and showcase these.

    Real Basketball – Casual Monster
    Slapshot: Rebound
    Football Manager 21 – Sports Interactive
    Hyper Scape – Ubisoft
    Critical Ops – Critical Force

    Let’s move on to highlight examples that demonstrate the need for some rapid improvement.

    Web Content that is being Auto-Clicked

    The findings below shocked us. We played two games from one developer, known for their implementation of in-game advertising technology.

    First, we saw an advert for TikTok which clearly disappeared and was replaced by this error. If you google zhiliaoapp.musically you will see that it is trying to load a TikTok website.

    Truck Driver City Crush – Naxeex Studio

    We then experienced the same thing, but for an ad by RSA. This time we managed to capture both the original ad and the error that followed.

    Real Gangster Crime – Naxeex Studio
    Real Gangster Crime – Naxeex Studio

    We finally realised what appeared to be occurring. Just after the ads were being displayed, they were actually being clicked through by the game itself acting as a mini Android browser. This happened with absolutely no player interaction causing it, other than looking at the screen. We wonder if the advertisers below are happy to pay for these conversions?

    We hope that @mrdfood isn't being charged for ad clicks… pic.twitter.com/e9EOrwh4WF

    — DIGACHAN | The Dynamic In-Game Advertising Channel (@DIGACHANcom) January 18, 2021

    Here's an in game ad for @eToro which the game auto clicked for us. Hope they weren't charged pic.twitter.com/XvEbLHux7S

    — DIGACHAN | The Dynamic In-Game Advertising Channel (@DIGACHANcom) January 19, 2021

    Have @disneyplus also become a victim of in game ad fraud? pic.twitter.com/NkNkHdOs39

    — DIGACHAN | The Dynamic In-Game Advertising Channel (@DIGACHANcom) January 19, 2021

    We are truly shocked to see these behaviours which have possibly led to a large number of click-through ad charges for the advertiser. As you will see from the below, RSA, Mr D Food, eTORO and Disney + brands have been seen in other games.

    “Auto-click seems based on gazetracking, which is a bad design for both player and advertiser, and can be detected as fraud. Ads should be opened explicitely, in a real fullscreen browser. This is the only way to connect premium brands with the industry and our belief at Gadsme”

    Luc Vauvillier – COO and Co-Founder of Gadsme

    Just how long these have been implemented and why no ad-fraud detection has occurred, we are not sure.

    Hype City – Hypemasters
    Hype City – Hypemasters
    School of Chaos Online MMORPG
    Rules Of Battle: FPS Shooter zula the king Game

    Creatives that are too small for the space:

    Next up is an ad that we spotted being ran across multiple games.

    Within the first game image below, the creative displays well and the brand stands out. You can even move your game character closer to it to take a look.

    School of Chaos Online MMORPG

    However, within the second set of game examples, whilst the same creative was loaded it failed to fill the allotted space. The brand name can be read, but due to the height and size of the placement, none of the other text could be..

    Rules Of Battle: FPS Shooter zula the king Game
    Mad Skills BMX 2 – Turborilla

    So who is impacted by this?

    Gamer: The ad is non-intrusive so it doesn’t interrupt gameplay, however, the ad stands out as not being quite right which could impact the players perception on the quality of the overall game. Which in turn could result in lost players.

    Advertiser: Assuming this counted as a valid impression, we’re not sure the advertiser would be happy with paying for this format representing their brand.

    Cropped Creatives due to poor sizing

    We provide a number of examples below where creatives were loaded into spaces that were clearly unsuitable for the designed space. Whilst the ad boards themselves look perfect for in-game advertising, the gamer would have a hard time figuring out, just what was being advertised.

    Hype City – Hypemasters

    According to an article published, Hypemasters experienced a 22% rocket of ad revenue after their in-game advertising implementation.

    Immediately after the publication, we have followed the game across multiple locations, but in actuality, have seen very few examples where creatives were loaded in a legible manner. We just hope that the examples we have reviewed weren’t counted as valid impressions and the advertisers were not charged.

    Without a bit of googling, we would have no idea that one of these ads was highlighting how RSA was named a Leader in the 2020 Gartner Magic Quadrant for IT Vendor Risk Management Tools (but we’re also not sure that the gamer would really care).

    Hype City – Hypemasters
    Hype City – Hypemasters
    Hype City – Hypemasters
    Mad Skills BMX 2 – Turborilla
    Drift Legends – Black Fox Entertainment / Starkom Entertainment
    Mad Skills BMX 2 – Turborilla
    Drift Legends – Black Fox Entertainment / Starkom Entertainment
    Hype City – Hypemasters
    Rules Of Battle: FPS Shooter zula the king Game

    Here’s a specific example where you can see just how the creative should have looked and how it actually displayed across two different games.

    School of Chaos Online MMORPG
    Rules Of Battle: FPS Shooter zula the king Game

    Watch the Small Print

    We spotted a campaign over in the US by Draft Kings within the Turborilla game, Mad Skills BMX2. At first glance, the creative looks to be well placed, however, this is a campaign that is promoting gambling within a game that could be accessed by children.

    The original campaign clearly has some additional small print warning of the dangers of gambling as well as conditions of the offer and how to redeem it. We imagine that this creative was not actually designed for gaming, and elsewhere, the user would have been able to click on the call to action. Our advice would be to keep any creatives focused on gambling and that require small print, out of a gaming environment.

    Mad Skills BMX 2 – Turborilla

    We saw a similar example over in Spain with a creative from eToro. Quite simply, creatives that have text and small print are going to distract the gamer and are unlikely to be legible within this type of environment.

    Rules Of Battle: FPS Shooter zula the king Game

    Skewing the Creative to Fit

    Simply skewing the original creative to fit in a box should be a big no-no, however we saw a few examples where exactly this happened.

    The below example shows an Audible creative that has been compressed, just to fit the available space. The latter example is an ad creative that we know is from 7-eleven, however, based on playing this precise game, the context of the advertiser would have been totally lost. Luckily, we had seen similar, well-displayed ads in other games for us to recognise what was being shown.

    Final Kick
    Final Kick
    Axis Football

    We don’t quite know what has happened here but the level of stretching on the ad, results in an extremely poor ad display. From what we can tell, there is a distorted call to action to open an app in the Google play store. However, the ad is not clickable within the in-game render.

    Hype City – Hypemasters

    Failure to Load

    Some of the games that we have tested resulted in multiple instances of images that simply failed to load with no fallback creative being loaded in its place.

    In one case we even saw an ad failing to load due to a requirement for the device to be in a different orientation. Something that the game didn’t allow and we question how the ad reached its way in.

    It’s important for the reputation of the developer, that everything looks like it’s supposed to be there and functions correctly.

    Gravity Zero – Vivid Games
    Drift Legends – Black Fox Entertainment / Starkom Entertainment
    Drift Legends – Black Fox Entertainment / Starkom Entertainment
    Mad Skills BMX 2 – Turborilla
    Mad Skills BMX 2 – Turborilla
    Mad Skills BMX 2 – Turborilla
    Hype City – Hypemasters

    Within the below example, while the original Gillette creative appears to be cropped, we wonder if having an adjacent ad fail to load would cause a negative brand experience recollection from the gamer

    Mad Skills BMX 2 – Turborilla

    Scroll Bars and Adapting the Area to Fit

    We’ve also come across a number of examples where the ad placement sizing actually seems to generate dynamically based on the creative. In first sample below, we can see how the backlight of the placement drowned out the advert. If you look even closer, you’ll even spot the horizontal scrollbar. In the second example, we can see another banner ad, but regardless of how close we got to it, we couldn’t read the text.

    These ads was clearly not intended to be shown in this game.

    Gravity Zero – Vivid Games
    Gravity Zero – Vivid Games
    Gravity Zero – Vivid Games

    Lack of Brand Recognition

    Clearly, if creatives are cropped, the gamer is unlikely to be able to identify the brand being advertised. Here are a few more examples of this. We loved the palm tree creative that was advertised from our hop over to Mexico, but unsure exactly who ended up paying for us to see it.

    Mad Skills BMX 2 – Turborilla
    Mad Skills BMX 2 – Turborilla
    Drift Legends – Black Fox Entertainment / Starkom Entertainment
    Mad Skills BMX 2 – Turborilla
    How the #Dadication campaign should have appeared
    Gravity Zero – Vivid Games
    Mad Skills BMX 2 – Turborilla

    Calls to Action

    We don’t think calls to action are a completely bad thing for in-game advertising. If you’re offering a discount code, and asking people to go shop a bit later (outside of the game), then that’s totally fine.

    However, creatives that were intended for the web and have a clear call to action for ad-clicks to be measured, should not have found their way programmatically into games.

    Over in Australia, we admired a real-world campaign that was produced by creative agency Thinkerbell. They cleverly created a range of interactive creatives to be used where customers could swipe or scan QR codes to reveal exclusive deals.

    We were therefore a little puzzled to see similar creatives in the below game which ask the player to swipe up to uncensor. We even tried stopping at the boards just to swipe…but nothing happened.

    It again raises questions as to whether this counted as a valid impression and should have been charged for. We also question how such a placement can be classed as being non-disruptive if the gamer needs to pause what they are doing to look at it and even try the action being asked of them.

    Gravity Zero – Vivid Games
    Gravity Zero – Vivid Games

    Game Play Stutters due to Ad Sizes

    Trying to incorporate multiple ad formats such as video and images at the same time, may cause gameplay to become interrupted. We witnessed examples of what appeared to be game stutter in the below two game scenerios.

    These ads would have looked great but they caused the game to lag significantly and didn't visually respond to the players command at the start. Real time video creatives need to be able to keep up with the game to ensure it plays correctly. pic.twitter.com/cgF7tM4ZeT

    — DIGACHAN | The Dynamic In-Game Advertising Channel (@DIGACHANcom) December 17, 2020

    To truly make #IGA work it must be seamless. Visible delays in attempting to load ads, could ruin the immersive gaming experience. pic.twitter.com/V1zlHCG9RU

    — DIGACHAN | The Dynamic In-Game Advertising Channel (@DIGACHANcom) December 15, 2020

    Ads that Chase You

    We’re on the fence about the next style of advertisement. On one hand, we really applaud the creativity of the game developer for putting ads in a location that follows the player. However, on the other hand, we feel that this may be crossing (or at least blurring) the line in terms of being non-intrusive.

    We headed a little further North to Canada for more #InGameAdvertising examples. Help, an Ad is chasing me! pic.twitter.com/tK5goxavzV

    — DIGACHAN | The Dynamic In-Game Advertising Channel (@DIGACHANcom) December 14, 2020

    Ad Stacking and Multiple IGA Providers

    Game developers can easily be tempted to just implement as much in-game advertising as possible to maximise their revenues but this can hurt both their game, the IGA companies and outrage the gamer.

    We’ve watched how one game, in particular, has made a series of changes within their live environment and we question the integrity of both the google and apple review process, given that some of the changes such as these were made without updates, and some with.

    These examples include creatives that are being placed on top of other content, ads being hidden by other boards that appear in front of them, and even floating video ads that don’t actually play.

    We even saw a TikTok ad promoting Halloween, displaying in December.

    Practices like this may not be entirely down to the IGA tech-provider, although arguably, they should have better contracts in place to ensure that a game developer does not abuse their own game and jeopardise the clients that they are accountable to and overall brand safety.

    From the game developers side, we’d like to see less testing being carried out in live environments, and real test environments being used instead.

    Dirt Trackin 2 : Sprint Games – Flying Squirrel Games
    Dirt Trackin 2 : Sprint Games – Flying Squirrel Games
    Dirt Trackin 2 : Sprint Games – Flying Squirrel Games
    Dirt Trackin 2 : Sprint Games – Flying Squirrel Games
    Dirt Trackin 2 : Sprint Games – Flying Squirrel Games
    Dirt Trackin 2 : Sprint Games – Flying Squirrel Games

    How can this be improved

    Firstly, we implore any game developers who are actively implementing in-game advertising to properly test the technology. Not only, test in your local region, but test in other regions via the use of a VPN app. You may find that locally, some great looking campaigns give the impression that the game is perfect, whereas a significant number of your gamers from other locations are receiving examples similar to those above.

    We ask game developers to be conscious of their audience. Whilst the ads need to be clear, they don’t really need to be in your face or follow you around the screen in order to be effective.

    We recommend that game developers ensure that any ad-technology being used has ad-fraud and brand safety protocols around it, with the ability for you to review and approve the content being distributed. After-all, it is not unheard of for claims of ad-fraud to result from advertisers being fooled into paying for something that is worthless to them, such as fake traffic, fake leads, or misrepresented and ineffective ad placement.

    Finally, we ask IGA companies to really think about the number of programmatic sources you are using to generate impressions to games. If these are sources that were not designed with gaming in mind, then chances are, the quality of the implementations are going to suffer. If you are running your network with no ad-fraud detection methods, then we suggest that this changes fast.

    Please let us know what you think in the comments and if you spot an example of any ad, we’d love to hear from you.

    Fraud Click detected for this in game ad showing automated ad clicks for @eon_de @postbank and @emp_de. pic.twitter.com/bqkksYM2NS

    — DIGACHAN | The Dynamic In-Game Advertising Channel (@DIGACHANcom) January 19, 2021

    This ad "flicker' was served and then auto clicked through to a cookie policy for @FASTWEB in Italy. Hope they didn't get charged for the ad click pic.twitter.com/reT9ix0CKp

    — DIGACHAN | The Dynamic In-Game Advertising Channel (@DIGACHANcom) January 19, 2021

    There was no ability for this game to be installed from this fixed in game browser so why were we taken to the app store and did @AmanotesGlobal get charged for this ad click? pic.twitter.com/UgxcJyPLp2

    — DIGACHAN | The Dynamic In-Game Advertising Channel (@DIGACHANcom) January 19, 2021

    This in game ad for @audible_com had an attempted click through by the game pic.twitter.com/7QrmyBjj9P

    — DIGACHAN | The Dynamic In-Game Advertising Channel (@DIGACHANcom) January 19, 2021

    We also hope that UK brand @Thermahood was not charged for auto clicks for their in game ad pic.twitter.com/uEbIROmxfj

    — DIGACHAN | The Dynamic In-Game Advertising Channel (@DIGACHANcom) January 19, 2021

    Read Part 2 of The In-Game Advertising They Don’t Show You

    Black Fox Entertainment Drift Legends Gravity Zero Hype City Hypemasters Mad Skills BMX 2 Naxeex Studio Real Gangster Crime Rules of Battle School of Chaos Starkom Entertainment Truck Driver City Crush Turborilla Vivid Games
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email

    Related Posts

    Mad Skills Motocross 3 Mind Blowing Trailer Reveals Release Date

    11 May 2021

    The In-Game Advertising They Don’t Show You – Part Two

    25 February 2021

    Comments are closed.

    Adverty & Apex Mobile Media Announce Partnership to Offer In-Play Gaming Inventory in Canada

    27 October 2022

    Adverty and Yazle announce exclusive in-game ad partnership in MENA region

    18 August 2022

    Adverty and Drive Ahead! developer Dodreams announce exclusive in-game ad partnership

    28 July 2022

    Adverty launches industry-first streaming video technology for In-Play™ ads in partnership with SeenThis

    14 July 2022

    Adverty’s Multi-patented and Industry-leading In-game Viewability Technology BrainImpression™ Now Available Within Oracle Moat

    5 July 2022

    Frameplay Announces New Attention Metric in Video Game Environments, Validated in Partnership with dentsu’s Attention Economy Team by First-to-Market Studies

    5 April 2022

    Adverty appoints Jonas Söderqvist as CEO as brands wakes up to the power of in-game advertising

    5 April 2022

    AdInMo expands its In-Game Ops Team

    18 November 2021
    DIGACHAN
    Twitter
    © 2023 DIGACHAN.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.